Short answer: No, not in the advocacy sense. Richard Haass, the veteran U.S. diplomat and Council on Foreign Relations president emeritus, affirms Israel's right to exist and to have responded militarily to Hamas, but since October 2023 he has been one of the more consistent establishment critics of Israel's wartime conduct in Gaza, going as far as calling Israeli policy "morally wrong" in mid-2025. As of August 2026, his public record reads as policy criticism from a friend, not cheerleading.
What Richard Haass has actually said and done
May 22, 2023: In a Project Syndicate essay titled "Israel at 75", Haass wrote that Israel faces a fundamental choice about its own identity, arguing that continuing to govern millions of Palestinians without citizenship is incompatible with remaining a full democracy.
October 15, 2023: Eight days after the Hamas attack, Haass published "What Friends Owe Friends" in Foreign Affairs, backing Israel's right to retaliate against Hamas while arguing that Washington should press Israel to restrain the scope of its military response in Gaza in order to preserve a path to peace.
November 27, 2023: On X, Haass argued that Israel should pair military pressure on Hamas with a clear political and economic offer to Gazans who reject Hamas, writing that "you can't beat something with nothing."
November 2024: In a Project Syndicate piece, Haass expressed hope that ceasefires in Lebanon and Gaza could open a genuine diplomatic process, provided political leaders recognized their own interests.
July 31, 2025: In a widely noted X post, Haass wrote: "People can debate whether what Israel is doing in Gaza constitutes a war crime, genocide, both, or neither. What cannot be debated is that Israeli policy is morally wrong and strategically flawed." He stopped short of endorsing the genocide label himself, but the framing drew wide attention as an unusually blunt statement from a foreign-policy establishment figure of his standing.
September 2025: In a Foreign Affairs essay, "A Palestinian State Would Be Good for Israel", Haass argued that Palestinian statehood, negotiated by a future generation of leaders, would ultimately serve Israel's own security interests, drawing a parallel to Anwar Sadat's peace overture after the 1973 war.
April 2026: Assessing the aftermath of a ceasefire in a Project Syndicate column, Haass wrote that the United States and Israel came out among the net losers of the period, while China and Russia gained ground.
Who is Richard Haass, and what are his Jewish and Israel ties
Richard Haass was born on July 28, 1951, in Brooklyn to a Jewish family (his mother was Marcella Rosenthal, his father Irving B. Haass). He served under four U.S. presidents, was U.S. Special Envoy to Northern Ireland, and led the Council on Foreign Relations from 2003 until stepping down in 2023, when he became president emeritus. He has spoken about Jewish identity needing active renewal across generations rather than being inherited automatically, and he was inducted into the Manhattan Jewish Historical Initiative's 2023 Hall of Fame. In 2015 he addressed the World Jewish Congress's American Section, urging that the United States and Israel "get back to a relationship in which we can confide" in one another. Those are the extent of his direct Jewish-communal and pro-Israel-institutional ties found in the public record; there is no evidence of Israel-related donations or of boycott participation or refusal on his part, either way.
His substantive record on Israel policy is that of a foreign-policy realist who has repeatedly criticized Israel's wartime conduct, from his October 2023 Foreign Affairs piece urging restraint through his July 2025 statement that Israeli policy was "morally wrong and strategically flawed," and his 2025 argument that a Palestinian state would serve Israel's own long-term interests. He consistently affirms Israel's right to exist and to have responded to the October 7 attack, and he frames his criticism as advice a friend owes a friend. But he does not present as a pro-Israel advocate; he presents as a critic of specific Israeli government policy, arguing from within a broadly pro-two-state, pro-U.S.-Israel-alliance framework.
The bottom line
Richard Haass is best described as a critical friend of Israel, not a supporter in the activist sense. He backs Israel's right to exist and to have responded militarily to Hamas, and he has personal Jewish roots and some ties to Jewish communal organizations, but his sustained public output since October 2023 has been pointed criticism of Israeli government policy in Gaza, culminating in his mid-2025 statement calling that policy "morally wrong." Shop Israel customers looking for a pro-Israel advocate will not find one in Haass; they will find a policy realist who argues that Israel's own long-term interests are served by restraint and by a negotiated Palestinian state.
Wear your support, no matter what the pundits say
Public figures will keep arguing about strategy and policy, but pride in Israel does not have to wait on any single commentator's verdict. If you want to make your own position clear, our I Stand With Israel collection has pieces built for exactly that, from bracelets to tees, designed for people who want to say where they stand without saying a word.
Related
Does Fareed Zakaria Support Israel?
Does Thomas Friedman Support Israel?
Does Samantha Power Support Israel?
Last updated August 2026. We update these profiles as the record changes.
