Short answer: No. Jimmy Kimmel was raised Roman Catholic, served as an altar boy as a child, and has described himself on air as a Christian. No reputable source documents Jewish parentage or ancestry on either side of his family.
What the record actually shows
- Born November 13, 1967, in Brooklyn, New York, as James Christian Kimmel. His father, James John Kimmel, worked at American Express and later as an IBM executive (Wikipedia).
- His mother, Joan Iacono, is of Italian descent. Her grandparents emigrated from Ischia, near Naples, after the 1883 earthquake. On his father's side, two paternal great-great-grandparents were German immigrants, and the family surname traces to the German "Kümmel," meaning caraway. Kimmel obtained Italian citizenship in 2025 (Wikipedia).
- He was raised Roman Catholic and was once an altar boy. The Times of Israel put it directly in a July 2017 report: Kimmel "is often mistaken as a Jew, he was raised Roman Catholic and was once an altar boy" (Times of Israel).
- November 30, 2017: Kimmel described his own faith on air. Responding to then-Alabama Senate candidate Roy Moore, who had accused him of wanting to mock Christian values, Kimmel said: "I happen to be a Christian too. And I will share what I learned at my church: at my church, forcing yourself on underage girls is a no-no." (Time).
- Late October 2012: his show ran a Jewish-themed bit called "Hipster or Hasid?" During its Brooklyn residency week, "Jimmy Kimmel Live!" showed close-ups of beards and asked viewers to guess whether they belonged to Brooklyn hipsters or Chasidic Jews (JTA).
- October 26, 2022: Kimmel took on antisemitism directly. After Kanye West's antisemitic remarks, the show aired a fake pharmaceutical ad for "Yentanyl," a cure for antisemitism with the generic name "Meshuggenehonum" and listed side effects including "a deep appreciation for Mel Brooks." Kimmel said on air: "Does anyone else feel like we're about to find out that for the past 20 years Kanye has been a Sacha Baron Cohen character?" (Times of Israel). Jewish reaction was mixed. Kveller critic Lior Zaltzman wrote on October 31, 2022 that "while this jokey ad seems to target Ye and fellow antisemites, most of what it does is peddle in cheap Jewish stereotypes" (Kveller).
- Still on the air in 2026. ABC suspended "Jimmy Kimmel Live!" on September 17, 2025 after his September 15 monologue about the Charlie Kirk assassination, Disney lifted the suspension on September 22, and the show returned September 23 to a record 6.26 million viewers (Wikipedia). On December 8, 2025, ABC announced a one-year extension keeping him hosting through May 2027 (ABC News).
Why people ask
Two things drive the question, and neither is evidence of Jewish ancestry. The first is his long relationship with Sarah Silverman, who is Jewish and speaks publicly about it. They met at the 2001 Friars Club roast of Hugh Hefner, announced a separation in July 2008, reconciled by that October, and ended the relationship in March 2009 (Newsweek). Kimmel married "Jimmy Kimmel Live!" co-head writer Molly McNearney in July 2013. The second is the steady run of Jewish-themed comedy on his show, from "Hipster or Hasid?" to the "Yentanyl" sketch, which reads to casual viewers like an insider's material. The surname adds to it, though "Kimmel" traces to the German Kümmel, not to Yiddish or Hebrew.
The misconception is well enough known that the show has joked about it. In a July 2017 episode, teenage fan Will Rubin of Media, Pennsylvania, who had thrown a "Jimmy Kimmel Live"-themed bar mitzvah, appeared on the show, and Jon Stewart turned up by surprise. "I'm Jon Stewart, I'm a talk show host as well. I was. A few years ago. And I'm a Jew," Stewart said, before adding of his host: "Don't be fooled by his learned-looking beard and his puffy, sad eyes. He's not rabbinical, he's just unhealthy." (Times of Israel).
Jimmy Kimmel and Israel
Kimmel has addressed Israel on air more than once. In an October 2023 monologue following the Hamas attack, he told viewers: "Our friends and allies in Israel, innocent civilians were killed and kidnapped by the terrorist organization Hamas. Israel is now at war. It's a nightmarish situation" (Times of Israel). On his October 2025 broadcast marking the ceasefire, he noted that "all 20 Israeli hostages are home after 738 days in captivity" and credited President Trump, saying "the bombing has stopped, the hostages have been released, and Trump deserves some of the praise for that" (Fox News). There is no documented trip to Israel or institutional affiliation on the record. For full details in our companion piece Does Jimmy Kimmel Support Israel?.
The bottom line
Jimmy Kimmel is not Jewish. His documented background is Italian Catholic on his mother's side and German-American on his father's, he was raised Roman Catholic and served as an altar boy, and he has called himself a Christian in his own words. The Jewish-themed comedy and the Sarah Silverman connection explain the confusion, but no reputable source documents Jewish ancestry on either side.
Celebrate your own story
If you are exploring your own Jewish identity or simply want to wear it where people can see it, our Star of David jewelry collection was made for exactly that. Every piece is designed and crafted in Israel, so what you wear carries a little of the place it came from.
Related
Does Jimmy Kimmel Support Israel? · Is Henry Cavill Jewish? · Is Rami Malek Jewish?
Last updated August 2026. We update these profiles as the record changes.
